Does a no-ball break a maiden?

Yes. The runs are charged to the bowler, so the over is not a maiden.

Is an over with byes a maiden?

It can be. Byes are not charged to the bowler.

Glossary

Maiden over

An over from which no runs were scored off the bat or as extras credited to the bowler, depending on how the league treats wides.

Photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0 ↗

A maiden is a full over of six legal balls in which the bowler concedes no runs charged to them. Byes and leg-byes do not break a maiden. Wides and no-balls do.

Scorers often forget the wide. An over with a wide in it is not a maiden, even if the batter scored nothing else.

Match questions

Questions scorers actually ask

01 Does a no-ball break a maiden?: Yes. The runs are charged to the bowler, so the over is not a maiden.
02 Is an over with byes a maiden?: It can be. Byes are not charged to the bowler.

Keep reading

From the cricket library

All articles

Photo: Acabashi, CC BY-SA 4.0LawNet run rate for club tablesNet run rate is runs scored per over faced minus runs conceded per over bowled, using the overs actually available when a side is all out.
Photo: Aravind Sivaraj, CC BY-SA 3.0BlogStrange ways to lose your wicketEveryone knows bowled, caught, and lbw. The Laws also contain a set of rare dismissals that scorers should recognise on sight, because they turn up perhaps once in a career and then have to be written correctly.
Photo: Wikimedia Commons contributor, Public domainGlossaryWicket-keeperThe fielder behind the stumps who keeps wicket and takes the ball the batter misses.
Photo: Aussie93, CC BY-SA 3.0GlossaryLBWLeg before wicket: a form of dismissal decided by the umpire. The scorer writes the decision, not the appeal.
Photo: Mike Pennington, CC BY-SA 2.0LawPowerplay, for people keeping the bookA powerplay is a block of overs with fielding restrictions. The scorer's job is to know which over the restriction starts and ends, not to umpire the circle.
Photo: Sam Hood, Public domainBlogThe players who changed what a career looks likeA handful of careers did not just accumulate runs and wickets; they changed what the rest of the sport thought was possible, and in some cases forced the Laws or the schedule to move.